Directions : In the following questions, a statement of assertion is followed by a statement of reason. Mark the correct choice as
Assertion : The Eustachian tube helps in equalising the pressures on either sides of the ear drum.
Reason : The Eustachian tube connects the middle ear cavity with the pharynx.
both assertion and reason are true but reason is not the correct explanation of assertion.
— Concept: This question tests your understanding of the structure and function of the human ear, specifically focusing…Concept: This question tests your understanding of the structure and function of the human ear, specifically focusing on the role of the Eustachian tube.
Why (B) is correct:
The assertion states that the Eustachian tube helps in equalizing pressures on either side of the eardrum. This is true; it opens periodically to allow air pressure in the middle ear to match the atmospheric pressure, preventing damage to the tympanic membrane (eardrum).
The reason states that the Eustachian tube connects the middle ear cavity with the pharynx. This is also true; this anatomical connection is precisely what allows it to perform its pressure-equalizing function.
However, the reason, while true, does not fully explain *how* it equalizes pressure. It only describes its anatomical connection. The equalization happens because this connection allows air to move in and out, but the reason doesn't elaborate on the mechanism of pressure equalization itself, only the structural link. Therefore, both statements are true, but the reason is not the correct explanation of the assertion.
Why other options are wrong:
- (A) both assertion and reason are true and reason is the correct explanation of assertion: Incorrect, as the reason describes the connection, not the mechanism of equalization.
- (C) assertion is true but reason is false: Incorrect, both statements are factually correct.
- (D) assertion is false but reason is true: Incorrect, both statements are factually correct.
Common Mistake: Students often assume that if both statements are true, the reason must be the correct explanation. It's crucial to evaluate if the reason *logically explains* the assertion, not just states a related fact.
NEET Tip: For assertion-reason questions, first determine if each statement is individually true or false. If both are true, then ask yourself: "Does the reason *explain why* the assertion is true?" If the answer is yes, then A is correct; otherwise, B is correct.
Correct Answer: (B)
both assertion and reason are true but reason is not the correct explanation of assertion.