Which one of the following does not have a pyramidal shape?
Source: https://www.lazynewton.com/questions/chemistry/chemical-bonding-and-molecular-structure/pyramidal-shape-934180
Quick Answer
Option B
— Concept: The shape of a molecule is determined by the hybridization of the central atom and the number of lone pairs…
Step-by-step solution
1AnswerB·
Concept: The shape of a molecule is determined by the hybridization of the central atom and the number of lone pairs and bond pairs around it, according to VSEPR theory. A pyramidal shape typically arises from sp3 hybridization with one lone pair on the central atom.
Why (B) is correct:
Let's analyze the hybridization and geometry of the central atom in each option:
- A) : The central atom is Phosphorus (P). P has 5 valence electrons. It forms 3 single bonds with three groups. This leaves 5 - 3 = 2 electrons, which form one lone pair. Thus, P has 3 bond pairs and 1 lone pair. The steric number is 4, leading to sp3 hybridization and a trigonal pyramidal geometry.
- B) : The central atom is Nitrogen (N). N has 5 valence electrons. It forms 3 single bonds with three groups. In , the lone pair on nitrogen is delocalized into the empty d-orbitals of silicon atoms (p-d bonding). This delocalization reduces the electron density around nitrogen, making it sp2 hybridized. With 3 bond pairs and effectively no localized lone pair, the geometry becomes trigonal planar. Therefore, it does not have a pyramidal shape.
- C) : The central atom is Nitrogen (N). N has 5 valence electrons. It forms 3 single bonds with three groups. This leaves 5 - 3 = 2 electrons, which form one lone pair. Thus, N has 3 bond pairs and 1 lone pair. The steric number is 4, leading to sp3 hybridization and a trigonal pyramidal geometry.
- D) : The central atom is Phosphorus (P). P has 5 valence electrons. It forms 3 single bonds with three groups. This leaves 5 - 3 = 2 electrons, which form one lone pair. Thus, P has 3 bond pairs and 1 lone pair. The steric number is 4, leading to sp3 hybridization and a trigonal pyramidal geometry. Unlike nitrogen in , the lone pair on phosphorus is less available for p-d bonding with silicon due to the larger size of P and less effective overlap, so it retains its pyramidal shape.
Option Analysis:
- A) : Has a pyramidal shape (sp3, 1 lone pair).
- B) : Has a trigonal planar shape due to p-d bonding (sp2, no localized lone pair).
- C) : Has a pyramidal shape (sp3, 1 lone pair).
- D) : Has a pyramidal shape (sp3, 1 lone pair).
Correct Answer: (B)